Home » Food and drinks, Restaurant Reviews

The Miele Guide

11 November 2008 11 Comments

There’s a new best restos list out, complementing (or verifying?) the Philippine Tatler guide and Manila’s Best Kept Restaurant Secrets books.

The Miele Guide list is compiled by a group of food critics in Asia, and names the top establishments in the region. The aim is to somewhat become the Asian version of the Michelin Guide. Local restos that made the 2008/2009 list are as follows:

* Li Li
* Shang Palace
* Le Souffle at Fernando’s
* Lolo Dad’s Cafe
Museum Cafe
Pepato
* Abe
* Cafe Via Mare
Chef Laudico Bistro Filipino
La Cocina de Tita Moning
Sentro 1771
Aubergine
* Bizu Bistro
Chateau 1771
Prince Albert Rotisserie
* Apartment 1B
* Heat
The Fireplace
Bellini’s
* Italliani’s
* Sugi
* Casa Armas Tapas Bar
El Cirkulo
Elbert’s Steak Room
Old Swiss Inn
People’s Palace
* Antonio’s Fine Dining — Listed as part of Asia’s Top 20 Best Restaurants (ranked #10)
Highlands Steakhouse
Kanin Club
Sonya’s Garden

(List from margauxlicious)
* = places I’ve already tried

Initial thoughts:
- Foodies all over blogosphere have started to blog about this book, mostly in praise and excitement. I would like to offer my slight disagreement to it though. At first glance, I don’t think it can match Michelin standards of credibility, what with its sporadic listing and lack of explained criteria.

- While the restos on the list are mostly deserving, there are a few up there that I find dubious and not at par with the standards I’ll expect of such a prestigious list. Italianni’s is, at the very least, the country’s 3rd best Italian restaurant (other than Pepato and Bellini’s)?? Ludicrous.

- In my opinion, there are a couple of equally (or more) deserving establishments that are missed out. Places like The Tivoli (Mandarin Oriental), Le Bellevue (Manila Diamond Hotel), Tosca (Dusit Hotel Manila), Lemuria (Horseshoe Village), Red (Makati Shangri-la), … list goes on. I believe any of these places deserve the distinction more than a few of those listed.

- I’ve only tried 13 out of 30 in the list.. gotta do some catching up! Anyway I have the whole of 2009 to do so

11 Comments »

  • Bing said:

    PB looks alert! Heeheehee :P

    [Reply]

  • sinch said:

    PB ka rin :p

    [Reply]

  • Cha said:

    i have been to 14, nyaks! ang takaw ko! :D

    [Reply]

  • sinch said:

    get it to 30 before the year ends! para takaw talaga hehe

    [Reply]

  • Javi said:

    ano ang PB? paraguas bing? haha uh oh lalabas na to sa google. somebody might be googling..

    [Reply]

  • Cha said:

    pwede!!! :D its hard to lose weight nga lang afterwards hehehe

    [Reply]

  • Ivy said:

    if u find yourself in clark, check out C’s italian dining just outside of clark special economic zone. it beats italianni’s anyday.

    [Reply]

  • sinch said:

    PB = patabaing baboy

    [Reply]

  • sinch said:

    haha onga :p sit on an exercise ball while at work hehe

    [Reply]

  • sinch said:

    thanks for the tip! Will keep that in mind

    [Reply]

  • gerry said:

    sorry margaux – but are you serious ? including italianis and sonya in the list is a big insult to the other restaurants in that list.

    CAV at the fort can easily beat italianis and sonya’s garden in terms of service, food and everything in between.

    [Reply]

Trackbacks

Leave your response!

Add your comment below, or trackback from your own site. You can also subscribe to these comments via RSS.

Be nice. Keep it clean. Stay on topic. No spam.

You can use these tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

This is a Gravatar-enabled weblog. To get your own globally-recognized-avatar, please register at Gravatar.